The Best Rueben Sandwich by jakewidmann

Jake Widmann

Home

Recipes

Contact

My Account

The Best Rueben Sandwich

jakewidmann

Cook

3 hr

No need to let me know that I should’ve smoked the brisket. I don’t have a smoker, neither do most people. Brisket is usually made in a smoker, but I'll show you how to confidently cook it in the oven! These Ruebens are a must!

Read more

US

original

metric

Picture for The Best Rueben Sandwich

US

original

metric

Ingredients

Rueben

5 lbs beef brisket

3 tbsp olive oil

2 tbsp coarse salt

10 slices rye bread

10 slices Gouda cheese

1 jar sauerkraut

Butter for bread

Spices

2 tbsp brown sugar

1 tbsp onion powder

1 tbsp garlic powder

1 tbsp paprika

1 tbsp salt

1 tsp black pepper

1 tsp red pepper flakes

Russian Dressing

¾ cup mayo

¼ cup ketchup

2 tbsp diced red onion

2 tbsp diced pickles

2 tbsp diced parsley

½ lemon, juiced

1 tbsp Worcestershire sauce

2 tbsp sour cream

1 tsp horseradish

Directions

Rueben

Step 1

Prepare your brisket by covering all sides of it in roughly 2 tbsp of salt. It’s best to leave it sit for up to 24 hours, but whatever amount of time you can spare will work just fine.

Step 2

Stir together your spice mixture. Pat meat dry with paper towel. Drizzle meat with a little olive oil and sprinkle rub in top of meat. Gently massage into meat. Repeat this to all sides of meat.

Step 3

Preheat oven to 250°. Double wrap brisket in foil and place into oven. Roast for roughly 1 hour per pound or until internal temp reaches 185°.

Step 4

Once brisket is done, remove from oven and let rest on a cutting board to allow juices to settle.

Step 5

Mix Russian dressing ingredients together. Place into fridge to allow flavors to marinate.

Step 6

Slice brisket into thin slices.

Step 7

Heat a large pan or large griddle. Butter one side of rye bread and place onto griddle. Cook until golden brown.

Step 8

Spread 1 tbsp dressing on bread. Top with slices of brisket, then cheese. Place into oven under broiler until cheese is melted. Top with sauerkraut, then more dressing and top slice of bread.

Powered by

Already have an account?

jakewidmann

© 2025 jakewidmann. All rights reserved.